Wednesday, 12 February 2014

Shining Light



Shining Light

At the end of the 3 months Winter Retreat, the sangha sits together to ‘Shine light’ on your practice giving both ‘flowers’ and ‘encouragements’.

This practice comes directly from the tradition that on the last day of the winter retreat (or the rainy season retreat) a monk (Or nun) should bow down in front of his brothers and ask, “Please, with compassion, shine light on me so that I can see my strengths and my weakness during the past three months of this retreat.” He must prostrate deeply to receive this guidance.

The collective insight of the Sangha is offered in the form of a letter. The letter always begins by mentioning the positive qualities of the person who has asked for guidance to help him or her strengthen his or her self-esteem. The weaknesses of the person concerned will be mentioned after, with details, and then the suggestions to help him or her to practice. All are written with the language of loving kindness and compassion.

 We used to do a similar thing in the ashram, but it was called a PIP process, where you were first invited to reflect on your practice and then residents were invited to give a Positive comment, then an Improvement, then another Positive comment so that the comments would finish on a positive note.  Not more than these 3 comments were allowed to be given, so that everyone had a chance to say something and nothing was to be repeated.

So as I sat down to shining lights for others, I was surprised that the format was flowers or positive points first and then the sharing ended with an encouragement or improvement.  I was especially surprised that the ‘encouragements’ were in the language of, ‘Don’t do this, don’t do that’, rather than, ‘Have you considered trying this?’ or, ‘Practising in this way helps me and I’d like to offer it to you as something to try’ etc.  I felt some comments were quite harsh and I didn’t always leave a Shining light session feeling full of light, even when the comments weren’t for me.

So I went to my own shining light not expecting to glow on the way out, and unfortunately, that was exactly the way it turned out.

I grew up fortunate to have good conditions to study, did well at school, was reasonable fit and flexible and got on well with everyone.  I did volunteer work, lived in different countries with completely different languages, cultures and ideas, but I always accepted others and their way and was always accepted as I was in return, so it has been an interesting experience to arrive here and to seem to be perceived as always doing the wrong thing.  Perhaps that is my wrong perception, but spending a year as a sole aspirant always receiving corrections and then receiving a lot of guidance since being ordained, it is a strange feeling to be perceived as, the ‘Naughty one’.  I’ve actually been called a rebel twice, which is an interesting label for me and one that I haven’t experienced before and is helping me to develop compassion for those who are seen as rebels in other areas of life.

And so the session began being asked to shine light on my own practice.

What did I see?


I shared that, sometimes guidance is hard to receive in the moment, as the shade of brown of a hat, size of a jacket or whether or not I study at a desk or on the floor seem very unimportant to me, but on reflection I realize that if they are so unimportant, then I can make small changes to do what makes the sangha happy, and it is very easy to flow with the sangha in this way.


Cultural areas will take time to transform, but I don’t expect to plant a seed and have a tree full of fruit the next day, so I am not forcing myself to make changes that seem unnatural at the moment, and I have confidence that by being aware and by being in the presence of the sangha, things will change naturally.


I didn’t come to Plum Village to develop a sitting, walking, eating practice but to really practice in the presence of a great teacher and a practicing sangha, and therefore it is very easy to attend the schedule and I enjoy spending this time with the sisters.  I especially value the time on rotation as it is a good opportunity to get to know sisters better.


In order to attend the schedule, I am happy to balance any space taking time to look inside, to study and have some time alone.  Alone time makes me appreciate together time and vice versa.  There is a good balance for me this way.  I know that the sisters would like me to spend more time with them, but for now I am finding the best balance for me and this as all things will change to adjust to periods of more together time and more silent time.


Since being ordained there has been Christmas, New Years and Lunar New Years celebrations and I have found myself caught in the business which has reflected in my walking.  I’ve often noted that I am walking fast and told myself to slow down, but my mind and body haven’t wanted to.  It’s only in the last week that I am starting to slow down again.  I am aware of this.

I assumed after sharing these things that they wouldn’t be mentioned again.

I was wrong.

The comments started coming from the youngest to the oldest and I learnt a lot.

What did I learn?

That the whole process is a bit like Chinese Whispers as someone will make a comment in Vietnamese, which another person translates into English, which a third person writes on a whiteboard, and a fourth person types up on a computer.

One comment was translated into English as, ‘Don’t move your hands when you join your palms’, which was written on the board as, ‘Don’t wave your hands around when you join your palms’ and goodness knows what the person typing on the computer wrote.

Another Sister vented her anger at a situation which obviously bothered her, but she had never bothered to come and speak to me about and so let it build up and blow up at the shining light.

The situation was that one day I was walking to Upper Hamlet.  Usually if we go out, we have to have a ‘Second Body’ (another person) with us, but we are allowed to walk alone if we have people in eyesight, and taking it as a good opportunity for quiet time and to get some exercise, I usually walk alone and walk fast.  As I was walking, I thought I heard a sister call out my name, but turning around to check, I saw a sister a long way off walking slowly, so I turned around again and kept walking.  I then heard my name again, so turned around and waited for the sister to reach me.  I explained that I was practicing fast walking and would she like to join me and she waved her hand at me as if to shoo me on, so I turned around and kept walking.

In the shining light, she expressed her anger that I walked too fast for her and left her alone when what she was doing was trying to support me to not walk alone and that she didn’t want to support me anymore.

What was written on the board was, ‘Don’t walk so fast that your second body can’t keep up with you’, which of course was a surprise because I never realized that she thought I was her second body.

One sister who is not in my bedroom or study room told me I should spend more time in my bedroom and study room, which was an interesting comment from someone who couldn’t know where I spend my time.

Another sister who has  completely different life experiences to me and views things very differently to me told me that if she says black, I say white, if she says yes, I say no and that I should look at my rebel attitude and why do I always have to be the rebel!

I can only say that my experiences in life mean that I don’t see things the same way and I’m perfectly happy if I don’t see things the same way as others.  My experience of living in many places means that I see that there are many ways to view things and do things in the world.

Of course you can’t answer back when people are shining light on you.

You just have to sit there and let people express their perceptions about you.

Most people get a long list of flowers and a few encouragements.  For me I got a few flowers and a lot of encouragements.

It’s an interesting experience and makes me look at why I care so much about what others think?

Why does it worry me that Thay (My teacher) will read a lot of misperceptions about me as the letter will be given to him?

How can I let that go without hardening my heart?

How can I remain true to my nature?

My favourite calligraphy with a saying from Thay is, 

Be Beautiful, Be yourself

How can I do that and still live in harmony with the sangha?

These are my questions.