I’m
struggling at the moment regarding the current topic of discussion about rules
or fine manners as they are called here.
The
current opinion is that all of the fine manners and precepts are what defines
us as monastics because they are not what lay people follow.
My
thought is that when we practice the Dharma as the Buddha shared, then this is
what makes us monastic, but the argument against this is that even lay people
can practice the Dharma, so this is not the defining quality.
Somehow
I seem to be struggling with this idea.
Today
again there was a discussion about rules and I said that when we create rules
that we are only setting people up to break them so maybe we shouldn’t have
rules.
This
wasn’t very well received.
I
was asked to explain my anarchist view but choose to keep quiet as I find one
view leads to another person’s opposite view and a never ending cycle of views
begin and I find that tiring.
My
uncle told me once that the only thing we have to agree on is that we disagree,
and I’m happy to live that way. If we
can accept each other in our disagreement, that’s fine with me.
But
it made me think.
What
did I mean? Where did that feeling and
view come from.
And
this is my refelction. . . . . . .
When
we have rules, we create a set of ideas to live by and when we fail to live by
them, we judge ourselves, and let’s face it, we can be harsh self critics.
When
others ‘break’ the rules, we judge them, endlessly comparing ourselves and
others. What happiness does this lead
to?
My
experience of living in Israel was that rules didn’t benefit the Palestinians,
nor vice versa.
The
rules of the Syrian Government haven’t brought happiness to Syrians.
The
rules of the Lebanese Christians may not bring joy to the Lebanese Muslims, nor vice versa
The
rules that we set are ideas in our heads and not the absolute.
There
are 14 precepts that Monastics and Lay people can take in this tradition, which
ask people not to get stuck in ideas, not even Buddhist ones. Here are the first three . . . . . .
The First
Mindfulness Training:
Openness
Aware of the suffering created by fanaticism and intolerance, we are determined
not to be idolatrous about or bound to any doctrine, theory, or ideology, even
Buddhist ones. We are committed to seeing the Buddhist teachings as a guiding
means that help us learn to look deeply and develop understanding and
compassion. They are not doctrines to fight, kill, or die for. We understand
that fanaticism in its many forms is the result is the result of perceiving
things in a dualistic or discriminative manner. We will train ourselves to look
at everything with openness and the insight of interbeing in order to transform
dogmatism and violence in ourselves and the world.
The Second
Mindfulness Training:
Non-Attachment to
Views
Aware of the suffering created by attachment to views and wrong perceptions, we
are determined to avoid being narrow-minded and bound to present views. We are
committed to learning and practicing nonattachment from views and being open to
other’s insights and experiences in order to benefit from the collective
wisdom. Insight is revealed through the practice of compassionate listening,
deep looking, and letting go of notions rather than through the accumulation of
intellectual knowledge. We are aware that the knowledge we presently possess is
not changeless, absolute truth.
Truth is found in life, and we will observe life within and around us in every
moment, ready to learn throughout our lives.
The Third
Mindfulness Training:
Freedom of Thought
Aware of the suffering brought about when we impose our view on others, we are
determined not to force others, even our children, by any means whatsoever –
such as authority, threat, money, propaganda,
or indoctrination – to adopt our views. We are committed to respecting the
rights of others to be different, to choose what to believe and how to decide.
We will, however, learn to help others let go of and transform narrowness
through loving speech and compassionate dialogue.
I
feel that if we were practicing the Dharma, practicing appropriate and timely
speech, practicing to recognize the arising and passing of feelings and mental
formations, practicing to recognize wholesome and unwholesome actions and
relating to others with a heart of love, of non harm, of understanding and
compassion, then what rules would we need?
Morals
we need, and the Dharma teaches us to begin with ourselves
There
was a comment that we came here to change ourselves and that’s why we chose to
live with rules but I don’t feel that the Buddha wanted us to get stuck in
rules. I think that the Buddha wanted us
to practice the Dharma.
And
perhaps the fact that I am writing this signifies that I am stuck in a view.
Let
me get back to practicing the Dharma
Love
your ‘anarchist’